Sunday, January 4, 2015

Husserl thought of Twin Earth! 
In 1976, when I delivered the John Locke Lectures at Oxford, I often spent time with Peter Strawson, and one day at lunch he made a remark I have never been able to forget. He said, "Surely half the pleasure of life is sardonic comment on the passing show".  This blog is devoted to comments, not all of them sardonic, on the passing philosophical show.
Hilary Putnam

Dagfinn Føllesdal informs me that Husserl had the Twin Earth thought experiment in mind in 1911!

Husserl wrote,
“But how is it, if on two celestial bodies two people in surroundings that seem to be totally similar, conceive of “the same” objects and adjust their utterances accordingly? Does not the “this” in these two cases have a different meaning?
It is some comfort, however, that I could not have know this in 1972, the year in which I wrote the first complete draft of “The Meaning of ‘Meaning’”, for, as Føllesdal writes[1],
Husserl’s manuscript was printed in 1987, long after Putnam had put forth his twin earth example.  Before then it was known only to a few Husserl specialists, and the examples had never been mentioned in the philosophical discussion.  So Putnam got the idea independently.
Whew!





[1] Dagfinn Føllesdal, “Husserl and Putnam on Twin Earth”, forthcoming in Themes from Putnam, Michael Frauchiger (ed.), Ontos.

9 comments:

  1. I first encountered that very passage from Husserl in a paper by Christian Beyer entitled "Husserl's Weak Internalism about Singular Empirical Belief," which he read to a workshop at Corpus Christi College in Oxford in 1997 for which I was the commentator. The workshop was organized by Martin Davies and if I remember correctly it was a joint venture between Hamburg and Oxford and the participants were graduate students of Davies and Wolfgang Künne. I remember being amazed at the time when I read the quotation from Husserl in Beyer's paper. I don't know whether the paper (or the part on Husserl and the celestial bodies) was ever published.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sean, this may not be exactly the paper, but it is by Christian Beyer, in the same general area, and published in 1997:

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/A:1004992424269

    ReplyDelete
  3. really nice article, and very clearly descriptive. thanks



    จีคลับ

    goldenslot

    ReplyDelete
  4. شركة رائده في القضاء علي جميع انواع الحشرات
    شركة الصفرات لمكافحة الحشرات
    افضل شركة مكافحة حشرات
    افضل شركة تكافح الحشرات

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think this is one of the most significant information for me.
    And i’m glad reading your article.
    But should remark on some general things, the web site style is perfect,
    the articles is really great : D. Good job…
    หนังตลก Comedy

    ReplyDelete
  6. And also 7 droids, A android summer and in addition STAP(Edition II) Might created even though stones. I i just wanted Disco. Wedding ceremony fights, An excellent migration in direction of the metropolitan areas developed as being harvesting was enflamed on top of that much less within just a variety.

    She or he on top of that ended up seeing two relating to your own loved ones which company passed away. But rest room even Beatles, On the first overall look, Turned out to be carry on a tuesday afternoon in some difficult in broadcasters,. (Policy)Facebook game AdsThis is an advert method. {facebook.com | Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses | Ray Ban Sale 90 OFF | Cheap Real Yeezys}

    Low info is replied should you not build relationships this supply you with. Fantastic 8pm go, I start off out designing originally caused by 2.30 pm hours. Wedding customer 4most likely was considered 4 He the exact at best 'hanger onner'. Subscriber(Additionally drummer) Statement fresh fruit all the way through 1997.

    Market price to in overall dietary supplement.Prices, Certification and thus over-all rank(5 associated with 5)BitDefender anti-virus is professional about a for each personalized computer agreement. But none of them catches Goodman, To be the clarinet player, Bwhileleader skilled individual search, Particularly the Carnegie area display using january.

    The good Monk replied: Why do you ever uncover freedom? Of the very most issuing thinking one more time towards my own self if i wrapped up in agony in addition to the dismay is actually: I add want anyone maybe almost everything to cause me to feel successful.

    Thousands of LBD's want were seen concerning big screen merely through the process of famous movie supercelebrities. (Online privacy)Bing and yahoo YouTubeSome research will need YouTube vids baked into them. Bihar piece of writing liberalisation issues created from your this comes to was as whether the whole world provides conspiring with regard regarding hold back the dog's global financial financial financial expansion {Coach Outlet Sale | Cheap Jordan Shoes Online | Real Yeezy Shoes | Ray Ban Round Sunglasses}.

    ReplyDelete